PO Box 248
100 West Edwards Street
Payson, IL 62360
Payson Farmers Mutual Insurance Company was organized in 1873 and is one of the oldest mutuals in the area. Farmers in rural areas believed that they should not have to pay as much for insurance since they did not have as many claims.
Permitted to operate in the following counties: Adams, Brown, Hancock, Pike, Schuyler, Calhoun, Greene, Scott, Morgan, and Cass.