Payson Farmers Mutual Insurance Company -150 Years
Mon - Fri

8:00 - 4:30

PO Box 248
100 West Edwards Street
Payson, IL 62360

Since 1873

Payson Farmers Mutual Insurance

Best Insurance

Professional Agent

Easy Claim


Best Insurance Agencies

Payson Farmers Mutual Insurance Company is a small Farm Mutual with its home office in Payson, Illinois and is authorized to insure property in Adams, Brown, Calhoun, Cass, Greene, Hancock, Morgan, Pike, Schuyler, and Scott counties in Illinois.  Being a local insurance company, we are able to take care of your needs without the hassle or inconveniences of those on Wall Street.  We offer many coverages to protect your property, and have an excellent financial stability to pay out any claims.  Contact one of our agents to get a quote today!

What We Insure

We Ensure Professional Insurance Services

Home Owner

Farm Owners

Form Policy


Service Line

City Dwelling


Equipment Breakdown

Earthquake Coverage

Happy Customer
0 +
Professional Agencies
Policy Holders
0 +
Years of Experience

Our Affiliation

Payson Farmers Mutual Insurance has Over 150 Years of Experience in the Insurance Industry.